You can read my review of Shroud of the Avatar on the official forums.
I think reviews are a good thing, but informative reviews are better. It’s been hard to read a lot of the reviews about the game as they are reviewing an incomplete game.
The games market has changed a lot, even over the past few years and I would hate to be a games journo these days as there is so much content and so many entrenched positions.
You can’t expect to please everyone and it’s daft to ever do so. Better to follow the advice of Kevin Kelly and aim for a thousand rabid fans, which I think we can all say Portalarium has done brilliantly.